The Ultimate (American) Cookie Challenge

(23 votes)10
1 month ago

#1  Buttons  20 seconds  54% correct rate

These cookies are an important part of banana pudding.

Nilla Wafers

Lotus Biscoff Cookies

Keebler Coconut Dreams

Famous Amos Chocolate Chip Cookies

#2  Buttons  20 seconds  54% correct rate

This was one of the first commercially baked products in America.

Fig Newtons

Lofthouse Cookies

Walkers Shortbread

Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies

Fig Newtons were created in 1891 in Massachusetts.

#3  Buttons  20 seconds  27% correct rate  

What's the name of these pink and white cookies with sprinkles?

Mother’s Circus Animal Cookies

Pink and White Frosties

Animal Crackers

100s and 1000s Cookies

Mother’s Circus Animal Cookies are shaped like lions, elephants, camels, rhinos, hippos, cows, and pigs.

#4  Buttons  20 seconds  64% correct rate

This is the top-rated chocolate chip cookie in the United States.

Chips Ahoy! Chocolate Chip Cookies

Choc-o-lot Cookies

Grandma's Chocolate Chip Cookies

Mrs. Field's Chocolate Chip Cookies

With so many chocolate chips, you can't take a bite without hitting one!

#5  Buttons  20 seconds  59% correct rate

What is the name of this crispy, peanut butter sandwich cookie?

Nutter Butter

Nutty Buddy

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut Pals

It's estimated that around 1 billion Nutter Butters are eaten every year.

#6  Buttons  20 seconds  82% correct rate  

What kind of cookies is Leonardo painting in this video?

Fudge Stripes

E.L. Fudge

Fudge Sticks


#7  Buttons  20 seconds  69% correct rate

What are these dunkable cookies?



DIY Dunkables

Fudge Dunks

#8  Buttons  20 seconds  78% correct rate

These cookies are essential when making s'mores.

Graham Crackers

Animal Crackers

Mrs. Field's Chocolate Chip Cookies

Lofthouse Cookies

#9  Buttons  20 seconds  78% correct rate

What is the name of this treat by Little Debbie?

Cosmic Brownies

Zebra Cakes

Pecan Spinwheels

Unicorn Cakes

They are called cosmic brownies because they were inspired by the cosmic bowling trend in the late 90s.

#10  Buttons  20 seconds  96% correct rate  

What cookie is being dunked in this video?


Strawberry Newtons

Mint Chocolate Milano

Enjoy Life

The number of Oreo cookies made each year would circle the Earth five times!